Monday, March 30, 2015

Berating Ignorance

Sometime around entering California a friend explained to me that using the word "retarded" was not a classy move. Since the southeast uses the adjective like mayo on a sandwich (that is, overzealously), it took awhile for for me to grasp why I shouldn't act like that and then, after, to train myself to stop doing it.

The average southern sandwich.

This experience is key for two reasons. One, because it was a time where someone "called in" for me. Calling in is a way of explaining a personally frustrating subject so that it is approachable and enticing to another person. It positively associates acting appropriately with being classy and gaining social acceptance - powerful motivators, as most people are social and like to be kept in good regard. Calling in is in contrast to "calling out" where in response to a frustrating subject a person goes "Boo. BOOOOO," and gets someone to leave, using social ostracism to negatively reinforce the consequences of an unwanted action. Pavlov and child studies have generally found positive reward to be more effective. You just need to have the time, patience, emotional sturdiness for it.


Toddlers don't like it either.

Secondly, she got me thinking about other forms of intellectual put downs, where they come from, and how it affects conversation. Why do we have so many put downs for failing to be the most quick witted?

Let's unpack that a little: in America, where capitalism preaches that only the most fit and adaptable survive (which isn't true; see the fitness and flexibility of any corporate manager), Americans are taught that being smart = getting what you want. Being quick = getting paid. Not being smart and quick, or at least one of them is equated with a fast track to starving in the street. Or more specifically, starving in the street while everyone purposefully ignores you, because you came to that position through your own inability to excel. Harsh! Also not true, because that's the point of federal safety nets. Most people have someone who will help them out in emergencies, too. This is perception of danger is nonetheless real in its impact on our collective psyche in America, and has created a lot of shame and fear around whether or not a person is "smart enough." If a person's intellectual skillset is low, or if it is criticized as needing improvement, it is seen as an economic and social death sentence.

Where ever fear and shame are present, defense mechanisms are soon to follow. When it comes to intellectual shame, this is what is going on when a person does something that is wrong and then says they didn't do it, or asserts that it's not important. They are afraid of the unexpected consequences, a lot of which include social punishment. It's more intimidating than you might think - whips and stones can break your bones, but social rejection can make people suicidal. Most people do not want to be an outcast if they can avoid it.

So what you get is people being incorrect and then being defensive when it's pointed out. This defensiveness makes people less willing to point out when a peer (someone outside a hierarchical work environment) is wrong, because it creates social tension they don't want to deal with. Those who do want to correct mistakes - anything from nitpicking grammar to reckless discrimination that gets people killed - are left with the option of creating a social rift or, in my case, trying to understand what makes that rift happen.

A major issue with the going model of intellect as worth is that intelligence has more to do with what support a person has received in their life than with a person's actual capabilities. Things like what access you had for exposure to new, interesting things, how motivated you become via positive emotional associations with that exposure, and repetition to both exposure and positive associations play roles in what and how well people learn.

Advanced knowledge in one area doesn't always seep into others, but it has been shown to make it easier to learn other skills. If you don't have the support structure in place to learn a subject well it's harder to get interested, have time, and devote resources to developing a deep understanding of it, much less for any other set of topics.

There's issues with what Americans perceive as intelligence, too. Most often declarative memory is put on a pedestal - recalling events or manipulating numbers from recalling STEM principals. Less valued is muscle memory, used in mechanical skills like building and repair, and the creative association and muscular control used by fine artisans. Emotional knowledge, like how to make someone feel valued, is discounted by all but CEOs who track it in their metrics and those with an interest in psychology. The 'parent epiphany' new parents describe is usually about learning how feeling relentlessly valued and loved impacts moral, motivation, and stamina. All these things are not a given everyone can do. They require intelligence and should get respect.

Physical access is another facet of this conversation - what physically and mentally a person is capable of doing. A person with dyslexia will have trouble spelling, a person with a bad back will have trouble lifting, a person with an issue that affects their mind and body will have more difficulty. But difficulty, while a struggle to overcome, doesn't mean death in America. 

So what are we afraid of?

I thought about this as I distanced myself from using "retarded." I thought what other words I could use to convey my meaning. "Stupid" was next in my line up, but like I said, that's more an issue of what you may or may not have been exposed to. "Bad," when I was interested in removing shame, was not going to work.

"Uneducated" and "ignorant" seemed best. Uneducated covered the idea that what a person was doing wasn't a good idea, but that it might be because they hadn't been exposed to better practices. Ignorant is a synonym of uneducated, but with a connotation that they are also being rude.

To a point these words still work with shame, but it shames lacking education or tact instead of a person's intellectual capabilities.

This is an important distinction to make, because in academic and business circles criticism is doled out with an understanding that it is to better a person and NOT to belittle them.

In giving you the opportunity to be critiqued most academic and business people are recognizing that you are a force in their field. They want to improve your skills and make their group shine brighter by setting a bar for reasonable standards.

"It's not personal" is a sincere phrase, because one of the core principals in academics and business is that people are dynamic, willful and impactable. They have the ability to change when given the steps and motivation to do it. What you present as today isn't the same as what you may present as with influence and encouragement. So when they critique you, it's not that you're a certain type of person - it's that your actions work or don't work for the situation at hand. Changing the action is changing the problem.

This isn't a concept that's widely understood. In social situations, a person's self-worth gets put on the chopping board long before they consider the actual action they are doing that is being critiqued.

The social reaction of people unexposed to academic and business models is to assume critique of actions are a person attack. Usually they're not - outside of politics, the point is not to get rid of a person, but to have an issue with a thing they are doing.

It only escalates when the critique is ignored.

But when there's an issue worth bringing up, how do you approach it? Many with a high capacity for knowledge are put out when someone says something they know is wrong, and are seen as belittling if they say something.

Handling the conversation like the gentlest of kittens seems to work. Being constructive in your criticism (a compliment sandwich, if you will) can help. Following it up with an unrelated, enjoyable topic increases bonding while still allowing for what needed to be said to be said.

Some things to remember - Don't correct for an end result with that person. For a person to change, the grievance is going to have to come from multiple sources that have emotional salience to the offender. Understand that some people are uneducated, and some people are willfully ignorant. They just might not want to hear why they're wrong. Some people aren't in an emotional place for growth. And if you push it, you're going to come off as a jerk. Some people are ok with that, some people don't want to waste energy to give themselves a negative reputation, and some people just like getting along with friends they don't agree on all things with. It's just something to be aware of.

A major reason you should voice your opinion - to push back on ignorance, or to guide a lack of education - is to show others that facts, perceptions, and good practice are important. But relationships still matter, and correcting a person doesn't do much good to them or you if you're hurting someone's self worth in the process.

Here's to being firm and friendly.





Some silly, insightful inspiration:
http://forum.thesims3.com/jforum/posts/list/674830.page






No comments:

Post a Comment