Friday, June 6, 2014

Collective Structures Pt II

I've lived in housing collectives since 2007 and have been researching their structuring since around 2010. What follows is a concise chunk of info on ownership, stability, and experience in collective living spaces in the States. It was collected from interviewing around 200 people who have lived in, started, or maintained collective structures. I restricted this article to basic set ups, and it may leave a variety of information out that I have neglected to mention or have yet to gather. Let me know if there's other information you think is beneficial!

The words "collective" and "cooperative" themselves have varying definitions, so as it's used here a housing collective runs on principals of clear communication and has shared group activities, labor, and funding.

This is not to say that all housemates do all activities and labor every time an event arises - that would wear a body out. People are more likely to rotate organizing and interacting with projects and events as their schedules and interests allow. Participation, interaction, and common goals are key in successful collective projects.


The 'collective' definition is one I like to utilize because it differentiates a housing collective from shared housing, where people live together to keep rent low and may or may not have common interests. Additionally, it separates the idea of collectives (groups working toward ideals together) from cooperatives (groups working together for a profit incentive, a business that generates cash and deals with taxes). Separating these terms can help distinguish your interests and intent when creating and maintaining housing groups.


The best headache you'll ever have


One of the first hurdles collective organizers face is creating a payment structure that works for residents within the fabric of a society that's individually - and at times, anti-collectively - oriented. This is a categorization of ways people organize structuring in housing collectives. Compare and contrast what you've experienced and see if they seem accurate.

The Structural Types of Housing Collectives

 

Direct Lease Rent


- A private landlord unassociated with the collective owns the dwelling
- Each resident has their own lease with the landlord
- Each person is responsible for their rent (and no one else's). Price usually determined by square footage of the living spaces.
Pros: Takes the bull out of billing, leaving people time to focus their energy on other aspects of the collective. Above the table, the landlord knows how many people live in the dwelling and is okay with it.
Cons: Finding people the house wants who qualify for a single lease with their own credit score.
Found in: Bay Area, Mid-Atlantic

 

Group Lease Rent


- A private landlord unassociated with the collective owns the dwelling
- Multiple residents sign the lease
- Group is joint responsible for rent
Pros: Above the table legally. Landlord usually knows about the collective nature of the house, is okay with multiple non-family members residing there.
Cons: Completely obtainable, but landlords usually need excessive PR through a point person to agree to it. If one person doesn't pay rent everyone suffers. Taking a name off a lease can have consequences, so when people move out some leave their names. This can create issues with liability. Bills, security deposits, and evictions are notable headaches.
Found in: So-Cal

 

Single Lease Rent


- A private landlord unassociated with the collective owns the dwelling
- One resident signs the lease
- Leaseholder responsible for rent, submits one check to landlord
Pros: Easy to find a place with the right credit score
Cons: Landlords who like single renter leases usually want no-fuss tenants. Unless they don't answer the phone they are likely to get calls about the collective, find out there's more than one person living in the residence and may move to evict. If residents don't pay rent, leaseholder suffers with no legal incentive for other housemates to pay differences.
Found in: College towns

 

Housemate-Owner


- A private landlord associated with the collective owns the dwelling, lives in it with renters.
- May be direct, group, or no written leases
- Owner responsible for mortgage, dealing with non-payment and eviction
Pros: Property modification! You can do amazing things if you all work well together.
Cons: Inherent hierarchy for project approval. Can foster a false sense of permanency for renters. A whole new world of liability toward disaster, house maintenance, and upkeep for city code. A lot of stress on the owner in negotiating billing with friends.
Found in: So-Cal

 

Friendly Landlord/Beneficial Dictator


- A private landlord or group associated with the collective owns the dwelling, lives elsewhere.
- Direct or Group leasing
- Dwelling is usually paid off at this point, financing is for personal gain or projects
Pros: Above the table. Familiar set up to regular renting, except landlord is interested in boosting collective living and encourages multiple people to live together.
Cons: May or may not be open to structural renovation. Hierarchy for project development. There tend to be issues with hands-on landlords in these situations, but less so if they support from another city.
Found in: So-Cal

 

Squats


- Owner has abandoned property
- No lease
- Utilities only - unless you're especially clever
Pros: Few bills. Interior freedom. All the projects, if you have a good crew
Cons: Capacity limits. Respect levels. Police harassment. Dealing with conflict resolution when you want to sleep.
Found in: Major cities and deserted towns

 

Group Owned


- Group owns joint property or individuals own adjacent property
Pros: You can do almost all the things if you click with each other
Cons: You have to be financially secure, limiting the demographics that can directly participate. Lawyers, brokers, bankers, and real estate agents are people you will deal with a lot in securing these places.
Found in: Rural areas adjacent to rich metropolitan areas by a few hours drive (LA, New England, DC)

 

Squat Turned Group Owned (The Unicorn)


- Abandoned, renovated, and turned over by the city because you all kept it up so long
Pros: no rent, all the projects, accessible to all demographics, access to legal process when people don't respect a space
Cons: Too badass to drink from common coffee mugs anymore, residents turn to chalices to hold their drink and never sleep again.
Found in: NYC

 

University Collectives


- A University funds dorm like dwellings for college students, who are allowed some level of self governance
- Direct leases
- Lots and lots of admin
Pros: Exposing college students to collective living. Creating jobs and enhancing legitimacy and recognition of the terminology.
Cons: Limited to college students. Project focus limited (but hey, working together).
Found on: Public Ivy campuses



That's all the housing collective structures I've researched in North America. All of them are viable and work best with people who are individually responsible, interested in building vibrancy in their area, and enjoy the company of others. There are probably more out there. If I missed some, send a message!

Toast

No comments:

Post a Comment